the judges were left in despair after America decided to vote out Songbird Pia Toscano on Thursday. The three judges were all praises for the Hollywood week wildcard.

Randy Jackson, a very vocal fan of the young lady, was in shock when Ryan Seacrest announced that Pia got the lowest votes; thus, eliminating her from the competition. Jackson clasped his mouth and repeatedly said “No,” in disbelief of viewers’ decision. Jackson said after her Wednesday’s performance that she did really good and just have to work on her moves to deliver an overall performance.

Jennifer Lopez, the only lady judge in this season, said that the 22 year-old dark-haired beauty from Queens, NY Pia Toscano is a great performer. She further said that she does not know what happened to America, and she is angry in shock.

Steven Taylor shared the sentiments of the other two judges saying that Pia is beautiful when she sings. Jackson, who was devastated by the results, said that the results made him mad; repeatedly shouting, “What’s going on?” Lopez, shed a tear when Toscano sang her final song in the competition.

Pia Toscano’s Wednesday performance was a breath of fresh air as she decided to present an up-beat song; a complete contrast to her usually ballad songs. Toscano took a huge risk with “River Deep – Mountain High” performance but all the judges agreed that she pulled it off.

The judges, along with the remaining finalists, cried with Toscano as she bids her final farewell to her fans and American Idol friends.